L'Oreal Skin Perfection 3 in 1 Puritying Micellar Solution Review + Comparison with Bioderma

Every single reader of my blog and their mother probably already knows about my obsession with Bioderma Micellar Solution (review here), so when bloggers started talking about a new possible dupe - L'Oreal Micellar Solution - I had to run to the store to pick one up and try it. So, is it really a dupe?


No. It is not. Despite some people claiming that it is exactly the same, it just cannot be compared to Bioderma. At least not in my book. Having said that, it is a pretty good cheaper alternative for those of you that don't want to spend a lot of money on a micellar solution. If I'm not mistaken, the 250ml Bioderma in my country costs about 12€, while the 250 ml L'Oreal one costs about 4€. Before I continue with the review or shall I say comparison, I think I should first clear some things up for those of you who are not really familiar with micellar solutions. In short, micellar solutions are water-like products that are supposed to remove make-up, cleanse your skin, and maintain skin's pH balance. They do not have to be rinsed off and are known for being perfect products for sensitive skin. 


Now you probably all want to know how good the L'Oreal Micellar Solution is compared to the Bioderma one... Technically, they both do their job, but the L'Oreal one has a few annoying characteristics. The first one is the opening where the product comes out. The opening is way too big. The solution pours out like nobody's bussiness and leaves a cotton pad completely soaked up, which is just unnecessary. I've used this solution about four times to remove my make-up and a third of it is already gone. When it comes to Bioderma, that same amount lasts me ages! 

Another thing is that you have to use up way more L'Oreal's solution than Bioderma's to remove the same amount of make-up, despite the excess of product in the first place. When I was removing my make-up a few weeks ago, I cleaned half of my face with Bioderma and half of my face with L'Oreal. With Bioderma, I needed to do two rounds like always - with the first soaked cotton pad I removed my full face make-up, and then went over the skin again to make sure I removed every bit of it. At this point, my face was completely clear of all make-up. When I went through with another soaked cotton pad, there were absolutely no traces of any dirt. But when I used the L'Oreal's solution, I had to use up four soaked pads before my make-up was completely removed, which is twice as much. And besides that, I also had to to do a lot of rubbing off, because my make-up didn't come off as easily, with swiping only, as it does with Bioderma. 

And lastly, I also experienced irritation every single time I was removing my eye make-up with the L'Oreal solution. My eyes start to sting whenever I get this product close to them, so from now on, I'll stay loyal to my Bioderma solution and keep using the L'Oreal one for spot cleaning my brushes instead. It works pretty good for that! 

How many of you have tried this product or maybe both of them? Are you team Bioderma or team L'Oreal?

40 comments :

  1. Niti ne bom probala lorealovega, ker sem cist prevec zadovoljna z bioderminim losjonom... Hvala za tale review, da mi ga ni treba kupit:))

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ja, Bioderma je res vsaj meni osebno (in kakor vidim tudi drugim) precej boljša. :)

      Delete
  2. Meni tudi ta Lorealova ne odgovarja. Mi draži oči in se mi zdi, da se malo peni. Je Bioderma boljša. Najljubša mi je pa Vichy-jeva :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. O, potem imaš ti isti problem z očmi. Res ne vem kako to, da jih draži, če piše da je za občutljivo kožo. Pa jaz niti nimam nekaj ekstra občutljive kože...

      Od Vichyja je pa še nisem sprobala. Zdaj sem se navadla na tole Biodermo in se mi kar ne ljubi drugih probavati. Pa še 2 litra je mam na zalogi, haha. Mogoče jo sprobam, ko vse porabim. :D

      Delete
    2. Vichyjeva je tudi zelo dobra. Če bi primerjala z Biodermino, bi rekla, da je malce bolj vlažilna oz. negovalna. Ampak, kar se tiče odstranjevanja make-upa je pa za odtenek vseeno boljša Biodermina, ker porabiš manj produkta. Moje mnenje.

      Delete
  3. Great comparison. I'd been wondering how they held up to Bioderma.
    Kallie @ But First, Coffee

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I guess the difference doesn't seem that huge at first sight, but when you try Bioderma, nothing can compare anymore, haha.

      Delete
  4. I haven't tried Bioderma, but when people started comparing the two saying L'Oreal one being an exact dupe, I bought it right away. I was quite disappointed because I found it to be only good for pre-cleansing than deep-cleansing. It didn't remove my makeup effectively. As a result I gave up my hope from Bioderma. Otherwise I so wanted to give it a try when I had a chance to get hold of it in France. xx

    Shang J.| The Feminine Crusade

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is definitely not an exact dupe. If you can get Bioderma, I would definitely recommend you trying it.

      Delete
  5. Vidim, da si prišla do istega zaključka kot jaz :) Bioderma je enostavno boljša in tudi meni ena flaša zdrži zelo dolgo. O L'Orealovi embalaži pa sploh ne bi. Kateri cepec si je izmislil ta dizajn. Imam še tonik v isti embalaži in sem ga pretočila v flaško na sprej.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Točno tako. Pri telih embalažah pa res ne vem kaj tuhtajo... XD

      Delete
  6. Jaz sem pa zelo zadovoljna s tole vodico... Ampak me vseeno srbi, da bi probala Biodermo. :D

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ti priporočam, da sprobaš še Biodermo. Meni je res ful boljša. :)

      Delete
  7. great post, love the look of this x

    http://atypicalenglishrose.blogspot.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  8. I am so close to caving in and trying Bioderma. It's a bummer the L'Oreal one irritated your eye! I have sensitive eyes so it's a no-go for me probably!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Quite a few people have now told me that it irritates their eyes as well, so I definitely wouldn't recommend it for removing eye makeup...

      Delete
  9. Its a shame its not as good as bioderma, but I doubt anything would convince me to change make up removers!
    xo Kirsty
    www.beautyisperfection.com

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thank you so much for this comparison review, Sandra. It's the best and most comprehensive I've seen. Neither L'Oreal or the Bioderma micellair waters are available in my country but they're at the top of my "if I ever travel or find affordable shipping to my country I'll get them right away" list. Judging from this review I'd skip the L'Oreal and go straight for the Bioderma. It seems like a nice budget alternative at first, but it's the same case with most expensive products: they have better performance or pigmentation so you need to use less, thus you use them up slower and actually save money (or it comes out to being the same value as the cheaper one).

    Don't know why a micellair review prompted me to write such a long comment, LOL. Sorry! xx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Haha, don't apologize! I LOVE long comments. :D
      And yes, you're totally right. I rather get something that works well and I will use all the time than a bunch of stuff that are just 'meh'. Thankfully, some drugstore make-up items are sometimes just as amazing as their high end alternatives, but when it comes to skincare, I've learnt that a bit more expensive products usually work way better.

      Delete
  11. I heard about this just to say today and was so happy to see you put up a comparison! I trust you as my resident Bioderma expert, haha, and I'm really sad to know this doesn't totally live up! I'm completely smitten with Bioderma and it's really nice for taking off makeup although it did take a little getting used. It would have been nice to have an alternative (cheaper one at that) but alas! Maybe if I run out of Bioderma before I can get some more I'll pick this up as an "in between" Okay, I'm done, thanks for the review Sandra! :D

    - Jess
    The Mod Mermaid

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Haha, thanks Jessica! Yeah, it might work as an in between product, but you'll see, once you get used to Boderma, it's hard to switch to something else. :P

      Delete
  12. uporabna objava :) bom poskusila biodermo. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hvala! Pa poročaj kako ti bo všeč. :)

      Delete
  13. Moje mnenje že poznaš, meni se zdijo vse micelne iste oz. z minimalno odstopanji. Lorealova mi pa celo edina odstrani maskaro. Emalaža pa resnično obupna, zato se vračam k Biodermi, ker na koncu pride ceneje.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ja, to že vem, haha. Jaz sem se pa prou matrala s tole L'Orealovo. Na nekaterih mestih sem morala drgniti, da sem spravla dol make-up. Maskaro sem si pa nazadnje odstranila z Biodermo, ker so me od L'Orealove tok oči začele peči samo od odstranjevanja senčke, da sem jo raje na stran dala. :/

      Delete
  14. Potem pa lahko meni rečeš, da sem čudna. Sem še imela Biodermin sample in ga primerjala z L'Orealovo in sem porabila isto število vatic, preden sta obe zadovoljivo odstranili makeup, Biodermina mi ni bila nič boljša. Je pa res, da L'Orealova malo draži oči, ampak jaz jo itak upirabljam samo za obraz, ker očesni makeup raje odstranjujem z Ombia odstranjevalcem, ki mi je boljši, ampak embalaža je pa katastrofalna, čisto preveč miceralne se uporabi naenkrat, ne vem, kaj so mislili, ko so tole dali na tržišče. Upam, da popravijo. Aja, pa cena v Müllerjuh ni več 4 €, amppak že skoraj 6, tako da to, kar Erika pravi, popolnoma drži. Glede na to, koliko L'Orealove miceralne porabiš naenkrat zaradi neumnega pakiranja, pride na koncu Biodermina ceneje.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Haha, nisi čudna, samo produkti pri različnih ljudeh delujejo drugače. Erika tut pravi, da so vse enake, Mateja je imela pa isto izkušnjo kot jaz. Mogoče je tudi od make-upa odvisno...

      Jaz micelarno uporabljam za odstranjevanje makeupa iz celega obraza, tako da me je to draženje oči ful zmotlo. Embalaža je pa itak pojem za sebe. Pa še podražili, da so jo? Lol. Potem se res definitivno splača Biodermo kupiti, ker če potegneš črto, res nič ne prihraniš. Pa še meni osebno je boljša. :P

      Delete
  15. I found that most drugstore micellar waters sting the eyes i hate the feeling it feels like your eyes are burning :(, this review was soo helpful im defo going to invest in bioderma it sounds like the perfect make up remover for eyes, great review again xx

    ~ VISUALCANDY INC

    ReplyDelete
  16. I've been debating whether to try the L'Oreal one or the Bioderma one but the Bioderma one sounds much better and probably works out as better value for money anyway because you don't need to use as much :) xx

    ReplyDelete
  17. I haven't tried neither of those too.
    I use a Sephora make-up removal and it works perfect for me so I'm not thinking of switching it at least at the moment.
    x
    Stella from a A Shiny Place

    ReplyDelete
  18. Za te 5 € res ni slaba, ampak porablja se pa tako hitro ne vem no, meni sta tudi ljubše Bioderma in Vichy če morm zbirat.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Tudi jaz sm mislila, da ne more bit neke velike razlike med tem in Biodermo. Ampak ko sem prvič sprobala Biodermo sem pa kar neko razodetje doživela :D Res se ne moreta primerjati. Še sreča, da sem si naredila zalogo Bioderme :D

    ReplyDelete
  20. Lorealove še nisem probala, mi pa Biodermina npr. ni čisto odstranila maskare- sem bila full razočarana. Še vedno prisegam na Vichy-evo, ki mi najbolj očisti obraz. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Aja? Meni jo brez problema odstrani. Je pa res, da ne uporabljam vodoodporne. Bom probala še Vichy ko Biodermo porabim. :)

      Delete
  21. I've no experience with micellar waters but every single L'oreal product I've put near my eyes has burned or irritated them. I think they're very chemical-ly (is that a word?!) compared to other solutions.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I totally get what you mean! I was using their toner ages ago and I remember it irritated my skin as well.

      Delete
  22. Oh, hvala za tole - sem že bila na tem, da si nabavim tole L'orealovo, ampak sem se k sreči premislila ;). Bioderma zmaga, pa Caudalie je tud super.

    xx

    ReplyDelete

Back To Top